user brows model relev versu examin ramakrishnan srikant sugato basu ni wang daryl pregibon consider work user brows model search engin result organ sponsor click rate ctr result product probabl examin user result time perceiv relev result probabl click examin past paper assum ctr result vari base pattern click prior posit variat sole due probabl examin show sponsor search result substanti portion chang ctr condit prior click fact due chang relev result queri instanc due chang probabl examin propos user brows model attribut ctr sole relev sole examin enhanc model user behavior relev examin model attribut ctr chang relev yield substanti predictor ctr model attribut chang examin slightli wors model attribut ctr chang relev examin predict relev model attribut ctr chang relev model attribut chang examin surprisingli find model predict ctr wors predict relev essenti evalu user brows model respect accuraci predict relev ctr 